Skip to main content
Contact Sales Support Careers
United States (English)
Americas
  • United States (English)
  • Canada (English)
  • Canada (Français)
  • Mexico (Español)
Europe, Middle East & Africa
  • United Kingdom (English)
  • France (Français)
  • Deutschland (Deutsch)
  • Nederland (Nederlands)
  • Other EMEA Locations
Asia/Pacific
  • India (English)
  • Australia (English)
UKG logo UKG logo
Search
Get started Get started
    • Solutions
      Solutions by Need
      People icon
      Human Resources
      Payroll icon
      Payroll
      Talent icon
      Talent Management
      People connected icon
      HR Service Delivery
      Clock with Person
      Time & Attendance
      Calendar day icon
      Scheduling
      Document check shield icon
      Compliance
      Chart bar statistics icon
      Reporting and Analytics
      Product Suites
      UKG Pro

      A culture-driven HCM suite designed to support your enterprise organization's needs.

      UKG Ready

      All-in-one HR solution to help leaner teams focus on growth and making a difference for your people, every time.

      View all products
      Make your workplace shine brighter with UKG AI
      Learn more
      Learn more
      Reference Image

      Discover the generative AI that shines a light on your data to illuminate the best path forward on your journey to creating a great workplace.

    • Customer Experience
      The UKG Promise

      With over 70 years of expertise with BOTH people systems and systems of work, no one knows people and how they work better than UKG.

      Our Promise
      Customer Experience

      We think you’re pretty special when you’re a UKG Customer. That’s why we build products designed to inspire your people — and your organization — to grow and thrive.

      Partner for Life
      Implementation
      Support Experience
      UKG Community
      Working Smarter Café
      Customer Stories
      Belle Tire

      UKG Pro streamlines and automates administrative and HR tasks, so that field teams and managers can spend more time with customers, and coach, train, and listen to their people.

      Eventide Senior Living Communities

      Eventide Senior Living Communities uses UKG to drive employee engagement and streamline workforce management and HCM, including cutting PBJ reporting time by 99%.

      See all customer stories
      Collaborate, learn, and get support for your UKG solution!
      Visit UKG Community Visit UKG Community
    • Resources
      • Research & Insights
        Research & Insights
        • By Business Need
        • By Type
        See all
        Growth icon
        Human Capital Management
        People icon
        Human Resources
        People connected icon
        HR Service Delivery
        Payroll icon
        Payroll
        Talent icon
        Talent Management
        Chart tree people icon
        Workforce Management
        Clock with Person
        Time & Attendance
        Calendar day icon
        Scheduling
        Document check shield icon
        Compliance
        Chart bar statistics icon
        Reporting and Analytics
        Lightbulb icon
        Product Info
        Video player icon
        Product Tour
        Article featured icon
        Analyst Report
        Document icon
        White Paper
        Book icon
        eBook
        Organization icon
        Industry Brief
        Chart bar icon
        Infographic
        News people icon
        Article
        Video player icon
        Webinar Replay
        Interactive
      Research & Insights
      • By Business Need
      • By Type
      See all
      Growth icon
      Human Capital Management
      People icon
      Human Resources
      People connected icon
      HR Service Delivery
      Payroll icon
      Payroll
      Talent icon
      Talent Management
      Chart tree people icon
      Workforce Management
      Clock with Person
      Time & Attendance
      Calendar day icon
      Scheduling
      Document check shield icon
      Compliance
      Chart bar statistics icon
      Reporting and Analytics
      Lightbulb icon
      Product Info
      Video player icon
      Product Tour
      Article featured icon
      Analyst Report
      Document icon
      White Paper
      Book icon
      eBook
      Organization icon
      Industry Brief
      Chart bar icon
      Infographic
      News people icon
      Article
      Video player icon
      Webinar Replay
      Interactive
      Events
      Tradeshows
      Conferences
      Webinars
      See all events
      Blogs
      The People Purpose Blog

      Your source for the latest life-work trends and ideas from UKG experts and leaders. Stay informed and put people first in all you do.

      Workforce Institute

      Think tank that helps organizations drive performance by addressing HCM and workforce management issues.

      Workplace Resources
      Great Place To Work
      Pay Equity Resources
      Human Insights
      UKG Developer Hub
      UKG Named a Leader in the Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Cloud HCM Suites for 1,000+ Employee Enterprises for the Sixth Time
      Get The Report
      Get The Report
      Reference Image
      Gartner Magic Quadrant 2023 Image

      Get a comprehensive understanding of the human capital management (HCM) market to help you determine the solution that best fits your organization’s needs.

    • About Us
      About UKG

      Learn more about UKG and how our HR solutions inspire workforces and businesses around the world to drive people-focused results.

      About Us
      Why UKG
      UKG Leadership
      Newsroom
      Awards & Recognition
      UKG Ambassadors
      Culture
      Belonging, Equity, and Impact
      Our ESG Program
      Partners
      UKG Marketplace
      Analyst Reports
      Careers

      Look to your future. If you're interested in working for a company that truly invests in their people to create a culture of belonging and innovation, we want you on our team.

      Careers at UKG
      Early Career & Internships
      Benefits
      Life at UKG
      Featured Locations
      FAQs
      Experience awesome at work.
      Search jobs at UKG Search jobs at UKG
    Contact Sales Support Careers
    United States (English)
    Americas
    • United States (English)
    • Canada (English)
    • Canada (Français)
    • Mexico (Español)
    Europe, Middle East & Africa
    • United Kingdom (English)
    • France (Français)
    • Deutschland (Deutsch)
    • Nederland (Nederlands)
    • Other EMEA Locations
    Asia/Pacific
    • India (English)
    • Australia (English)
    Search Get started Get started
    Talent icon
    Talent

    Writing a performance review: What to include and how to boost effectiveness

    December 2, 2020
    Manager writing a performance review
    • Share
    See all blog stories See all blog stories
    Stay up to date with The People Purpose Blog
    Subscribe via email Subscribe via email
    Subscribe via RSS

    Written By

    Rachel Rapoza, Product Marketing Manager, FPC
    Rachel Rapoza
    Product Marketing Manager

    Rachel is a part of the Ready team at UKG and focuses on innovative payroll and talent management strategies. She holds an APA FPC certification.

    Topics

    Performance Management Performance Management Talent Management Talent Management

    While performance reviews may have a bad rap, they play a critical role to aligning employee goals with your organization’s objectives as well as improving employee engagement. But I'm sure you've all heard that before, so I'm going to give you a good reason why to start.

    The thing to remember when you face down the inevitable stress of performance review season is your people do actually find them useful – in fact, a study done by HR.com found that 64 percent of employees said reviews give them helpful feedback and 45 percent said reviews provide them with good face time with their managers.

    The issue, however, is that according to SHRM the overwhelming majority of managers feel unprepared to deliver effective performance reviews. So it's important for HR teams to prep and train your managers to write performance reviews. That preparation will be mission-critical to ensuring that reviews are effective and meaningful.

    So how do you actually assist managers in writing performance reviews? Here are three simple questions to answer:

    What's required when writing performance reviews?

    While there are few legal requirements around what is included in a performance review, the content needs to be legally defensible. This means that managers conducting performance reviews should keep these principles in mind:

    1. Use specific examples: When writing performance reviews, vague phrases such as “you’re doing good work” and “keep it up” really don’t add value to any conversation and don’t give employees specific feedback. It’s critical to point to specific examples of activities or behavior in order to effectively communicate to the employee what “good” looks like (or conversely, what “needs improvement” looks like). Also, using concrete examples provides solid documentation should your organization need to use the performance review when making promotion and termination decisions.
    2. Connect performance to business impact: When employees understand their role’s impact on the business, they’re more likely to be more engaged and have higher performance, but according to a recent Robert Half study over half of employees do not understand the impact of their role on their organization. When providing examples in a review or summarizing an employee’s performance, it is important to outline how their work adds value to the organization. For example, if an employee provided exceptional customer service that resulted in higher than normal customer retention, you could connect that to the increase in revenue retention for your organization.
    3. Include competencies: While performance goals measure “what” your people should accomplish, competencies (i.e. collaboration, effective communication, adaptability, etc.) measure “how” they accomplish them. Typically, organizations can have a set of competencies for their organization and/or have competencies based on the employee’s role. Reviewing an employee’s performance as it relates to competencies can identify behaviors or habits that can help them become more effective in their role.

    How do you give feedback on performance?

    Providing employees with feedback (both positive and constructive) is a key tenet of a performance review and can offer employees valuable information that can have a profound impact on their career. However, when delivered poorly, feedback can have a detrimental impact on their engagement and potentially their likelihood of staying with your organization, so it's important for managers to provide feedback effectively.

    Here are a few tips for effectively delivering feedback HR can pass on to managers:

    1. Focus on a few specific examples: While documentation of performance should ideally take place throughout the year, a performance review should focus on a few key and specific examples of great performance or areas for improvement. This makes it easier for the employees to understand while not overwhelming them with too many examples.
    2. Separate the person from the action: When providing feedback, especially constructive feedback, how you describe what needs improvement is very important to ensuring an employee doesn’t feel personally attacked. You can do this be focusing on the action that needs improvement vs. on the person who needs improvement. For instance, if an employee missed an opportunity to prevent a mistake, feedback should read like “in this [specific instance], you could have shown more initiative by doing [this] which would have prevented [specific mistake]” vs. saying "you were not proactive in this [specific instance]”. The latter example could make an employee feel personally attacked by describing them as a “not proactive” person.
    3. Focus on development: Another important piece of providing critical feedback is focusing on how an employee can improve their skills. By highlighting areas for development, managers can shift the conversation to focus on the opportunity to improve. For employees, this approach can signal that their manager or organization is willing to invest time or resources to help them become more successful in their role – which can help keep them engaged in their work.

    What are optional additions when writing a performance review?

    The typical performance review covers employee goals and sometimes competencies, but increasingly, organizations are looking for additional info and data points to provide managers to help better inform their reviews. Some optional things you could encourage managers to include in a review are:

    • Employee self-assessments: Providing employees with the opportunity to do a self-assessment of their performance can provide managers with helpful insights into how their employees view their own skills and areas for improvement.
    • Peer feedback: Gathering feedback from an employee’s peers can be very helpful for managers to get a full view of employee performance, especially as it relates to competencies. However, it's important for HR or managers to review all peer feedback and reword as necessary before presenting to an employee to ensure that it effectively communicates the feedback without disengaging the employee or identifying the feedback provider.
    • Development plan: After a performance review has been conducted, your managers may identify areas for development for their people. Including a formal development plan can help keep employees (and managers) accountable for their development over the next year. This could take the form of a simple list of courses, potential projects or assignments, or conferences that an employee participates in or leads.

    Conclusion: These performance steps may seem simple, but they're strategic

    Performance reviews might not be your managers' favorite activity, but they matter to employees perhaps now more than ever. They're also critical to you as an HR professional in terms of building your own strategic impact.

    A key part of building an effective HR-business partnership is proving the impact your people initiatives, processes, and activities have on achieving business goals. Digging into your HR technology to show performance trends and all the goals different departments have accomplished can be a great way to do this, but in order for that data to have the strategic impact you want your managers have to be aligned with you on what information the include in performance reviews and how they conduct them. If you'd like to see more about where you should focus to build powerful HR-business partnerships, check out our recent research with HCI. It'll give you a great head start.

    Read the Great Reset Research Report

    • The People Purpose Blog
    • Writing a performance review: What to include and how to boost effectiveness

    Related Stories

    Women shaking hands over a desk
    The People Purpose Blog

    The Need for Speed in Your Talent Acquisition Strategy

    What’s driving the demand for fast hiring? Learn how to balance speed with your talent acquisition strategy using hiring software and HR automation.

    Woman smiling in front of presentation on a screen.
    The People Purpose Blog

    How To Quantify Recruitment ROI

    Talent acquisition teams are leveraging new metrics for executive buy-in. Learn recruitment ROI formulas that can change your department’s perception from a cost center to a value driver.

    The public sector can help educational institutions and government agencies find and retain the best talent in the new world of work.
    The People Purpose Blog

    Why Creating Purpose at Work Is Key to Retaining Talent

    Job seekers and employees today are increasingly focused on finding purpose in what they do. Read how promoting the mission-driven nature of working in the public sector can help educational institutions and government agencies find and retain the best talent in this new world of work.

    UKG logo

    Footer menu

    • Human Capital Management
      • Human Resources
      • Payroll
      • Talent
      • Reporting and Analytics
    • Workforce Management
      • Time & Attendance
      • Scheduling
      • Compliance
    • Product Suites
      • UKG Pro
      • UKG Ready
      • Industry Solutions
    • Customer Experience
      • Implementation
      • Support Experience
      • UKG Community
      • Customer Stories
    • About Us
      • Why UKG
      • Culture
      • Our ESG Program
      • Leadership
      • Newsroom
      • Careers
      • Privacy and Security

    Sub Footer

    • Modern Slavery Statement
    • Accessibility
    • Cookie Choices
    • Cookie Notice
    • Terms of Use
    • Trademarks
    • CCPA Notice
    • Licenses
    • Privacy Notice
    © 2023 UKG Inc. All rights reserved.

    Kronos SaaShr, Inc., a UKG Company (NMLS ID#1698726) provides money transmission services on behalf of UKG Inc. customers and in connection with certain UKG products.